Heating System Cost Comparison Calculator: Gas, Electric, Heat Pump & Propane

To compare heating systems fairly, you have to give them the same job. This heating system cost comparison calculator takes one annual heating load and works out the yearly running cost of four systems: a natural gas furnace, electric resistance heating, an electric heat pump and a propane furnace. You enter your fuel and electricity prices and the efficiency of each system, and it returns four annual costs side by side.

Heating & Cooling Cost Calculators

Heating System Cost Comparison Calculator

Compare estimated annual running cost across gas, electric, heat pump and propane heating, for the same total heating load.

$
per therm
%
$
per kWh
$
per gallon
%

What do you enter in the heating system cost comparison calculator?

The load box takes the heat your home needs over a year, in BTU. Its starting value is 60,000,000. The box carries a BTU per hour label, but the formulas use the number as total BTU for the year, so treat 60,000,000 as 60 million BTU of heating a year. If your fuel bills show gallons or therms, you can convert them using the energy content in the table below.

Input Starting value
Annual heating load 60,000,000 BTU
Natural gas rate $1.20 per therm
Gas furnace AFUE 95%
Electricity rate $0.15 per kWh
Heat pump HSPF 9
Propane rate $2.80 per gallon
Propane furnace AFUE 92%

The formulas

Each system turns the same load into fuel use, then multiplies by price. The energy contents come from the U.S. Energy Information Administration’s Btu conversion table: one therm of natural gas is 100,000 Btu, one kilowatt-hour is 3,412 Btu and one gallon of propane is 91,452 Btu. The calculator rounds propane to 91,500.

Gas cost = Load ÷ 100,000 ÷ (AFUE ÷ 100) × Gas rate
Electric resistance cost = Load ÷ 3,412 × Electricity rate
Heat pump cost = Load ÷ (HSPF × 1,000) × Electricity rate
Propane cost = Load ÷ 91,500 ÷ (AFUE ÷ 100) × Propane rate

AFUE is the share of fuel energy that becomes heat. HSPF is a heat pump’s seasonal heat output divided by the electricity it uses, in Btu per watt-hour, so a higher number means less electricity for the same heat. Electric resistance heating turns each kWh into 3,412 Btu, which is why it needs no efficiency input.

Worked examples

Worked example: the starting values

Gas = 60,000,000 ÷ 100,000 ÷ 0.95 × 1.20 = 631.58 × 1.20 = $757.89
Electric resistance = 60,000,000 ÷ 3,412 × 0.15 = 17,585 kWh × 0.15 = $2,637.75
Heat pump = 60,000,000 ÷ 9,000 × 0.15 = 6,666.7 kWh × 0.15 = $1,000.00
Propane = 60,000,000 ÷ 91,500 ÷ 0.92 × 2.80 = 712.76 gal × 2.80 = $1,995.72

Worked example: a smaller load and different prices

A 40,000,000 BTU load, gas at $1.50 per therm with a 90% furnace, electricity at $0.20 per kWh, a heat pump of HSPF 10, and propane at $3.00 per gallon with a 90% furnace:

Gas = 400 ÷ 0.90 × 1.50 = $666.67
Electric resistance = 11,723.3 kWh × 0.20 = $2,344.67
Heat pump = 4,000 kWh × 0.20 = $800.00
Propane = 437.16 ÷ 0.90 × 3.00 = $1,457.19

Heat pump rating and cost

For the 60 million BTU load at $0.15 per kWh:

HSPF Electricity used Annual cost
8 7,500 kWh $1,125
9 6,667 kWh $1,000
10 6,000 kWh $900
12 5,000 kWh $750

What the comparison leaves out

It compares running costs only. It does not include the cost of buying and installing each system, maintenance, or any fixed charges on your gas or electricity bill. It uses one electricity rate and a single seasonal rating, so a heat pump’s real efficiency on very cold days is not modelled. Because the load is the same for all four, it also does not show how your home’s demand would differ.

Finding your annual heating load

Start from your fuel bills. For gas, multiply the therms used for heating by 100,000. For propane, multiply gallons by 91,500, then multiply by the furnace efficiency to get the heat delivered. Using a full year of heating bills gives a better base than a single month.

Which system is cheapest at the starting values?

For the 60 million BTU load, the annual costs rank like this:

System Annual cost
Natural gas furnace, 95% AFUE $757.89
Electric heat pump, HSPF 9 $1,000.00
Propane furnace, 92% AFUE $1,995.72
Electric resistance $2,637.75

The order depends on your prices. Gas wins here because $1.20 per therm is cheap next to $0.15 per kWh.

Fuel prices and the result compared

For the same load, gas at 95 percent AFUE uses 631.58 therms. Heat pump electricity at HSPF 9 is 6,666.7 kWh.

Gas price per therm Gas cost Electricity per kWh Heat pump cost
$0.90 $568.42 $0.10 $666.67
$1.20 $757.89 $0.15 $1,000.00
$1.50 $947.37 $0.20 $1,333.33
$1.80 $1,136.84 $0.30 $2,000.00

Worked example: converting bills to a heating load

Suppose last winter you burned 700 therms of gas for heating in a 95 percent furnace. The heat delivered was:

Load = 700 × 100,000 × 0.95 = 66,500,000 BTU

For propane, 600 gallons in a 92 percent furnace gives 600 × 91,500 × 0.92 = 50,508,000 BTU. Enter the BTU figure in the load box, then compare what the other systems would cost for the same heat.

Running cost compared with published scenarios

Scenario Electricity Gas Heat pump COP Heat pump a year Gas a year
U.S. averages $0.16/kWh $1.20/therm 2.5 $1,126 $758
Favorable to heat pumps $0.13/kWh $1.50/therm 3.0 $761 $947
Cold, high electricity $0.20/kWh $1.00/therm 2.0 $1,759 $632

The calculator’s starting values give gas $757.89, which matches the U.S. average scenario. Its heat pump figure of $1,000 at $0.15 per kWh comes to $16.67 per MMBtu, which sits between the U.S. average and the favorable case. The three scenarios show that the answer can flip, so enter your own prices before you decide.

Frequently asked questions

How do I convert HSPF to COP?

Divide HSPF by 3.412. An HSPF of 9 is a COP of 2.64.

Does the comparison include installation costs?

No. It compares running costs only. For the purchase price of a heat pump, use the air source heat pump cost calculator.

Mark Danny

Mark Danny

Mark Danny builds and maintains the free calculators and guides on Area of Irregular Shapes Calculator. Every calculator page explains its formula and shows a worked example, so you can check the working yourself. Spotted a mistake or have a suggestion? Email gulsher.hingoro101@gmail.com.

Articles: 559