Heat Pump vs Furnace Cost Calculator: Compare Annual Running Cost

Whether a heat pump or a gas furnace is cheaper to run depends on three prices and two efficiency ratings. This heat pump vs furnace cost calculator takes your annual heating load, the electricity rate, the heat pump’s HSPF, the gas rate and the furnace’s AFUE, and returns the annual running cost of each.

Heating & Cooling Cost Calculators

Heat Pump vs Furnace Cost Calculator

Compare estimated annual running cost of a heat pump against a gas furnace, from your energy rates and system efficiencies.

Total BTU needed for the season.
$
per kWh
$
per therm
%

The starting values are a 60,000,000 BTU load, $0.15 per kWh, HSPF 9, $1.20 per therm and 95% AFUE. At those prices the heat pump costs $1,000.00 a year and the furnace $757.89, so the furnace is cheaper.

How do you compare heat pump and furnace running costs?

Convert the heat you need into the units each fuel is sold in, then multiply by its price.

Heat pump cost = Load ÷ HSPF ÷ 1,000 × Electricity rate
Furnace cost = Load ÷ 100,000 ÷ (AFUE ÷ 100) × Gas rate

Where the load is the BTU you need over the season, HSPF is the heating output in BTU per watt-hour of electricity, one therm is 100,000 BTU, and AFUE is the share of the gas that becomes heat.

Worked example: the starting values

Heat pump = 60,000,000 ÷ 9 ÷ 1,000 × 0.15 = 6,667 kWh × 0.15 = $1,000.00
Furnace = 60,000,000 ÷ 100,000 = 600 therms
600 ÷ 0.95 = 631.6 therms × 1.20 = $757.89

The furnace is $1,000.00 − $757.89 = $242.11 a year cheaper at these prices.

At what electricity price do they cost the same?

With HSPF 9 the calculator’s equivalent COP is 9 ÷ 3.412 = 2.64. The table shows the break-even rate for four combinations, with AFUE at 95%.

Gas price HSPF 9 HSPF 12
$1.20 per therm $0.114 per kWh $0.152 per kWh
$1.80 per therm $0.171 per kWh $0.227 per kWh

At the default $0.15 the heat pump loses with HSPF 9, because $0.15 is above $0.114. With HSPF 12 it wins, because $0.15 is below $0.152, though only just. Read your own rates from your bills.

How the inputs move the result

Electricity price and HSPF change the heat pump cost, and the gas price and AFUE change the furnace cost.

Change Annual cost
Heat pump at $0.10 per kWh, HSPF 9 $666.67
Heat pump at $0.12 per kWh, HSPF 9 $800.00
Heat pump at $0.20 per kWh, HSPF 9 $1,333.33
Heat pump at $0.15 per kWh, HSPF 10 $900.00
Heat pump at $0.15 per kWh, HSPF 12 $750.00
Furnace at $1.80 per therm, 95% AFUE $1,136.84
Furnace at $1.20 per therm, 80% AFUE $900.00
Furnace at $1.20 per therm, 98% AFUE $734.69

Worked examples for different homes

Worked examples

Cheap electricity

At $0.10 per kWh and HSPF 9 the heat pump costs $666.67 a year against $757.89 for the furnace, so it saves $91.22.

Expensive gas

At $1.80 per therm the furnace costs $1,136.84, so the default heat pump at $1,000.00 is $136.84 cheaper.

An older furnace

An 80% AFUE furnace at $1.20 per therm costs $900.00, which is $100.00 less than the default heat pump and $142.11 more than the 95% furnace.

What the calculator leaves out

It uses one HSPF for the whole season and does not include equipment cost, installation, maintenance or incentives. It also does not model a heat pump losing capacity in very cold weather or the use of backup heat. For four-way comparisons including propane and electric resistance heat, see the heating system cost comparison calculator.

Frequently asked questions

Is a heat pump cheaper to run than a gas furnace?

It depends on the prices. With HSPF 9 and a 95% furnace at $1.20 per therm, the break-even is about $0.114 per kWh, and above that the furnace is cheaper.

How do I calculate heat pump running cost?

Divide the annual heat load by HSPF and by 1,000 to get kWh, then multiply by the electricity rate. 60,000,000 BTU at HSPF 9 and $0.15 is $1,000.00.

How do I calculate gas furnace running cost?

Divide the load by 100,000 to get therms, divide by AFUE, then multiply by the gas rate. The default gives $757.89.

What is HSPF?

It is the heating output in BTU per watt-hour of electricity over a season. HSPF 9 is equal to a COP of about 2.64.

Does the calculator include equipment cost?

No. It compares annual running cost only, so add purchase, installation and maintenance separately.

Mark Danny

Mark Danny

Mark Danny builds and maintains the free calculators and guides on Area of Irregular Shapes Calculator. Every calculator page explains its formula and shows a worked example, so you can check the working yourself. Spotted a mistake or have a suggestion? Email gulsher.hingoro101@gmail.com.

Articles: 559