Propane vs Oil Heating Cost Calculator: Compare Seasonal Cost

Propane and heating oil are sold by the gallon but carry different amounts of heat, so the cheaper price per gallon is not always the cheaper fuel. This propane vs oil heating cost calculator takes your annual heating load, the price of each fuel and the system efficiency, and returns the seasonal cost of each.

Heating & Cooling Cost Calculators

Propane vs Oil Heating Cost Calculator

Compare seasonal heating cost between propane and heating oil for the same energy demand.

$
per gallon
$
per gallon
%

The starting values are a 60,000,000 BTU load, propane at $2.80 per gallon, oil at $3.50 and 85% efficiency. At those prices propane costs $2,160.08 a season and oil costs $1,783.82.

How do you compare propane and oil heating costs?

Divide the heat you need by the fuel’s energy per gallon and by the efficiency to get gallons, then multiply by the price.

Propane cost = Load ÷ 91,500 ÷ Efficiency × Price
Oil cost = Load ÷ 138,500 ÷ Efficiency × Price

Where 91,500 and 138,500 are the calculator’s BTU per gallon for propane and heating oil, and efficiency is a decimal such as 0.85. The calculator uses one efficiency for both fuels.

Worked example: the starting values

Propane = 60,000,000 ÷ 91,500 = 655.7 gal
655.7 ÷ 0.85 = 771.5 gal × 2.80 = $2,160.08
Oil = 60,000,000 ÷ 138,500 = 433.2 gal
433.2 ÷ 0.85 = 509.7 gal × 3.50 = $1,783.82

Oil is $2,160.08 − $1,783.82 = $376.26 cheaper at these prices, even though a gallon of oil costs more, because it holds about 51% more heat.

What is the break-even propane price?

Propane matches oil when its price per gallon is oil’s price times the ratio of the two energy values. With oil at $3.50 that is 3.50 × 91,500 ÷ 138,500 = $2.31 per gallon.

The default $2.80 is above that, which is why oil wins. Per million BTU, propane costs 2.80 ÷ 91,500 × 1,000,000 = $30.60, and oil costs 3.50 ÷ 138,500 × 1,000,000 = $25.27.

How do the defaults compare with published figures?

Price case Propane per gallon Oil per gallon Propane season Oil season
Calculator defaults $2.80 $3.50 $2,160.08 $1,783.82
2024 EIA averages, same 85% $2.50 $3.87 $1,928.64 $1,972.39

With the 2024 averages the result flips and propane is cheaper by $43.75. Those figures work out to about $27.34 per million BTU for propane and $28.17 for oil. The defaults therefore favor oil more than the 2024 averages do, so replace them with the prices on your own delivery tickets.

Worked examples for different homes

Worked examples

Gallons used

At 85%, the default load needs 771.5 gallons of propane or 509.7 gallons of oil. At 98% propane needs 669.1 gallons, and at 87% oil needs 497.9.

Finding your own break-even

Multiply your oil price by 0.66. At $3.87 that is 3.87 × 91,500 ÷ 138,500 = $2.56 per gallon, so propane has to be below that to win at the same efficiency.

Running the 2024 prices

Enter $2.50 and $3.87 at 85% to get $1,928.64 and $1,972.39. Then change the efficiency in the calculator for the fuel you are replacing.

How the load, efficiency and oil price change the comparison

The first table keeps the default prices and the 85% efficiency and changes the annual heating load.

Annual load Propane season Oil season Oil is cheaper by
40,000,000 BTU $1,440.05 $1,189.21 $250.84
60,000,000 BTU $2,160.08 $1,783.82 $376.26
80,000,000 BTU $2,880.10 $2,378.42 $501.68

The gap grows with the load, but the ranking does not change, because both costs scale with the load in the same way. Only the prices and the efficiency can change the order.

Efficiency

Efficiency reduces both costs in proportion. For the 60,000,000 BTU load, 80% efficiency gives $2,295.08 for propane and $1,895.31 for oil, 85% gives $2,160.08 and $1,783.82, and 90% gives $2,040.07 and $1,684.72. A better appliance lowers the bill for either fuel, but the calculator uses one efficiency for both, so enter the figure of the system you plan to run.

The break-even propane price

The break-even moves with the price of oil. At $3.00, $3.50 and $4.00 per gallon of oil, propane breaks even at $1.98, $2.31 and $2.64 per gallon. Compare today’s quote for propane with the figure for today’s price of oil, and the cheaper fuel is the one below its break-even.

Frequently asked questions

Is propane or heating oil cheaper?

It depends on the prices. With oil at $3.50 per gallon, propane is cheaper only below $2.31 per gallon at the same efficiency.

How do I compare them per million BTU?

Divide the price by the BTU per gallon and multiply by 1,000,000. Propane at $2.80 is $30.60 and oil at $3.50 is $25.27.

Does the calculator include equipment and tanks?

No. It compares fuel cost only, so add equipment, installation and tank costs separately.

Does the heating load change which fuel is cheaper?

No. The load scales both costs equally, so it changes the size of the saving but not the ranking. At 40,000,000 BTU oil saves $250.84 and at 80,000,000 BTU it saves $501.68.

How does efficiency affect the comparison?

It lowers both costs in proportion. At 90% efficiency the 60,000,000 BTU load costs $2,040.07 for propane and $1,684.72 for oil.

Mark Danny

Mark Danny

Mark Danny builds and maintains the free calculators and guides on Area of Irregular Shapes Calculator. Every calculator page explains its formula and shows a worked example, so you can check the working yourself. Spotted a mistake or have a suggestion? Email gulsher.hingoro101@gmail.com.

Articles: 559